Comparing Google, MSN, And Yahoo
By: Aaron Wall
2007-01-22
I recently read Gord Hotchkiss's second eye tracking study, and it rocks. It is quite meaty in nature, and well worth a read for any serious search marketer.
Links: Gord Hotchkiss, second eye tracking study
It costs $149, but is a great value if you are a lover of search or a professional search marketer.
On to a few interesting highlights...- Google is perceived to have better relevancy than other search engines, and is able to help concentrate attention at the top of the search results due to being primarily branded as a search site (instead of a portal), starting from a clean page full of white space, better use of real estate (by doing things like showing fewer ads on non-commercial queries, or showing them less prominently), better SERP formatting (including whitespace and perhaps even formatting using the phi ratio), and better ad targeting.
- On average for Google and Yahoo the ads are viewed as more relevant than the organic results.
- Interaction with search results is quick (roughly 10 seconds). We scan for information scent rather than fully analyzing, with a bias toward a semantic map that matches our goals.
- Many top ranked search results guide toward a specific bias (say shopping) even when that makes them somewhat irrelevant for the user intent based on the search query. For generic queries we are biased toward research. Brand specific queries are more commonly biased toward purchasing. This biased intent may be fully decided before we even enter a query, and make us prone to ignore or specifically look for certain sites, or types of sites. Using strong emotional words (such as scam) or words that indicate research purposes (such as compare or reviews) may evoke a better CTR.
- There is a direct connection to the thalmus to the amygdala which allows the amygdala to emotionally react to a sensory impulse before the neocortex can evaluate the input, thus when the neocortex does logically evaluate something you may already have that emotional bias worked into the equation, and thus try to justify it as being right...I think this was also mentioned in Blink, but is an interesting point.
- The psychological noise of portal pages and the sensationalism associated with traditional headline news may erode emotional confidence when searching from a portal page, as compared to Google, which may be viewed as a way to escape the real world and do what you want.
- We like to scan things in groups of 3s.
- When text is placed inside an image it is easy to ignore it due to the feeling of images as low value or low information spaces likely with noise.
- Google AdWords discounting for click relevancy ends up creating a self reinforcing market where the top ads are the best in many markets, especially in competitive marketplaces with high search volumes. Low volume keywords easier for bids to organize position...higher volume keywords primarily driven by ad CTR.
Those were just a few points from an information dense report which was refreshingly well put together. And in a market where so many people talk about getting top rankings it is great to see someone writing about how people interact with search results, and how to leverage them for their full value.
Gord has his head wrapped around search. When Greg Boser recently called out Did It:
"I also didn't really consider David's comments newsworthy. After all, he certainly isn't the first PPC zealot to write a shitty article telling the world that SEO consultants were a high-risk waste of precious marketing dollars, or that organic SEO is as simple as hiring a monkey and giving them the URL to Google's webmaster guidelines."
Gord added further context to the debate by talking about search from the perspective of the searcher, which is a topic oddly lacking in nature in discussions in our industry, given how much we talk about rumors of everything else.
Comment
Tags: Gord Hotchkiss, SEO
Add to  Del.icio.us |  Digg |  Reddit |  Furl
Have a bookmark! - 
About
the Author:
Aaron Wall is the author of SEO Book, a dynamic website offering marketing tips and coverage of the search space, free SEO videos, and free SEO tools. He is a regular conference speaker, partner in Clientside SEM, and publishes dozens of independent websites.
|
|
|
| |
Do you have a search site?
Submit it free to the internet's best search industry directory.
» Click Here
|
| |
Search Engines
Google, Yahoo, MSN...
Search Marketing
Marketing, Budget, Planning...
Pay Per Click
Bid, Price, Quality...
|
SEO Companies
Optimization, Manage, Company...
SEO Tools
Track, Search, Create...
Analytics
Statistics, Counter...
|
|
| |
|
» Submit your site for FREE «
|
|
iEntry 10th Anniversary
RSS
Contact
